Summary from 161 ratings
On Rate.fm, fans have rated Mitski’s catalog across 9 albums from 161 opinions, with an overall average of 8.1/10. The top-rated Mitski album is The Land Is Inhospitable and So Are We (2023) with a 8.5/10 average from 21 ratings, followed by Puberty 2 and Bury Me At Makeout Creek. The discography on Rate.fm spans 2012 to 2026. My Love Mine All Mine ranks as the highest-rated Mitski song on Rate.fm with a 8.9/10 average.
Nothing’s About to Happen to Me
“wit and warmth define her best album yet”
Nothing’s About to Happen to Me
“mordant, melodic melancholy from the best songwriter of her generation”
Laurel Hell
“Made up in equal parts of emotional pop bangers and riveting electronic anomie, Mitski’s hotly anticipated fifth album does not disappoint. This Japanese American indie artist’s strides towards the mainstream are laced with resonant themes; disembodied hands, cleanliness and “the dark” recur as images. The hooks are sharp. A series of tunes skew hard towards sleek, oversaturated 80s pop. In addit”
Nothing's About to Happen to Me
“Reviewing 2026 projects: Project: #011 Title: Nothing's About to Happen To Me Artist: Mitski Tagline: Mitski's chaotic mindset and overthinking is covered by the lush front that Mitski puts on musically. This isn't really my kind of music but I thoroughly enjoyed the project, with it representing a chaotic mindset, and a musical representation of overthinking, with some really relaxing content too. This project centring Mitski's mindscape and a very one sided conversation to another someone. The project itself doesn't feel like it is for everyone, but for the select amount of people it's for, it's a great project. In a Lake is an interesting start to the project, starting off with something so unusual for an intro track, though it is done pretty well I guess, quite a chill track, and Mitski's vocals are quite comforting. The beat drop is amazing as well. Track felt like a "calm before the storm" moment as soon as Where's My Phone?'s chaotic energy hits. Where's My Phone? felt quite underwhelming however, outro is great. Cats is a relaxing cover-up to a chaotic mind-scape, and I love that. The track itself is quite relaxing and a very easy listen for anyone as a matter of fact. If I Leave is similar to Cats, however just more a bit more chaotic and messy. Instead of Here and I'll Change for You feel like Mitski is plotting but vaulting a huge, desperate vent to the other someone that is on the side of the album. Charon's Obol feels more like a healing mentality than anything we've seen on the project so far, the background vocals are amazing. Lightning feels cyclical almost, almost perfectly mirroring In a Lake (album opener). The main progression though throughout the album is the large, healing wound. FAVOURITES: I'll Change For You, Instead of Here LEAST FAVOURITES: Where's My Phone? Simplified rating: 7/10”
Lush
“Lush is my favorite album ever. I’m a big fan of Mitski and I really truly relate to. Mitski does poetic songwriting incredibly well. Lush is somehow both raw and beautifully refined. One of my favorite tracks is Bag of Bones. In my perspective, the track dives into sexual relationships and feeling disconnected from them entirely. The idea of having sex and feeling used after. He “illuminates her pores” and “tears her apart” but she has this connection she doesn’t want to break and I just think this is incredibly beautiful and poetic. She also is losing her personality as well. “Do what you came here to do but first open up a window for me” She is so disconnected from this sexual relationship but she stays in it because she can’t leave. Overall Lush, as an album,dives into toxic relationships, toxic gender roles, and toxic emotional baggage. It’s by far my favorite Mitski album and I have nearly every album on vinyl.”
Bury Me At Makeout Creek
“mitski really is my favorite artist. i can’t stress my love for her and her art. the guitar riffs, the vocals, the angst. this album personably asociable with my jump for adolescence to adulthood. i feel like this jump wasn’t graceful and came about in a quick and unpredictable way. it’s a super short album at only 30 minutes long but in those 30 minutes she is able to pack in so much meaning”