The Dismemberment PlanBest The Dismemberment Plan Albums Ranked
7.5
Avg Score
14
Opinions
6
Albums
8
Reviewers
Summary from 14 ratings
On Rate.fm, fans have rated The Dismemberment Plan’s catalog across 6 albums from 14 opinions, with an overall average of 7.5/10. The top-rated The Dismemberment Plan album is Change (2001) with a 8.6/10 average from 3 ratings, followed by Emergency & I and A People's History of the Dismemberment Plan. The discography on Rate.fm spans 1999 to 2013. You Are Invited ranks as the highest-rated The Dismemberment Plan song on Rate.fm with a 8.8/10 average.
Emergency & I
“**The Short Review:**If you consider yourself a fan of groundbreaking pop, go out and buy this album right now. Now. Get up. Go. **The Long Review:**Judd handed me a purple children's book and said, "Check this out." The hardback felt about the size of a gatefold double vinyl album. In bold letters, the cover proclaimed *The Worst Band in the Universe!* Immediately we opened the book in an attemp”
Change
“Change is something fans of D.C.'s The Dismemberment Plan have grown accustomed to over the years, as the band has proven to make vast leaps in maturity with each album. Somewhere between the release of their clumsy 1995 debut, *"!"*, and 1997's more balanced but no less raucous *Is Terrified!*, the band discovered the advantages of rock balladry and pensive lyrics. With 1999's *Emergency & I*, th”
A People's History of the Dismemberment Plan
“Love them or hate them-- for there are few who find themselves between these extremes-- The Dismemberment Plan were an undeniably forward-thinking band, innovative without sacrificing accessibility, and always looking to forge new ground. It's possible that their tendency to continually transform themselves hastened their breakup, which, if you haven't been following the indie rock newswires, has ”
Emergency & I
“I genuinely can't sit through this album. 4.3 because I get the ideas and I hear how influential it was. But basically every single interesting idea ended up getting done more successfully elsewhere. This album feels like an atonal disaster that never resolves. I don't get how people actually enjoy it. Even Pavement, which seems to have done a lot of these ideas way better, I don't find particularly interesting or enjoyable. But it has at least some bright spots that I can't really find in this album. In the back of my mind is the idea that maybe I just need to listen to it a lot more. Maybe! But for now you get reamed. L bot”
Emergency & I
“What I imagine a losers panic attack is ”