pastemagazine reviewed Day and Night by Carly Rae Jepsen 4h
What’s most striking about the pop singer’s eighth album is how spatially and texturally interesting it sounds: choral vocals darken the corners, time-stretched samples burst apart when beats drop, instruments wash into each other. — Somehow, Carly Rae Jepsen can make tangible the electricity of a fleeting glance or a bitten lower lip. She writes open-armed pop songs from the center of her heart, capturing and crystallizing those fluttery feelings at their genesis before they can snowball into more complex forms. They’re usually about the small moments in a romance—the anticipatory tension of following a new lover to their room, the record-skip palpitations when they text you back, the ache of knowing your words aren’t landing, the final wave goodbye—blown up them up into all-consuming, widescreen images. She’s ecstatic and cringe; she’s down bad and yearning; she’s desperately trying to be cool when you’re around. The trail of broken hearts she walks must eventually lead to salvation, right?
Jepsen’s Sisyphean search for love—a hero’s journey we will all take continuously as our lives molt and tangle and compound—found a real foothold in the swoon of an imagined eighties, all Day-Glo synths and gate-reverbed snares, her mezzo-soprano soaring through sticky hook after sticky hook. E•MO•TION, her 2015 breakthrough, was a bubblegum triumph, its on-the-sleeve ardor and occasional blunt horniness so relatable they were completely, blissfully overwhelming.
With each successive album, she added shading and contour to her doe-eyed emotional availability, finding a few new sounds for her repertoire—mostly disco—but always returning to that well of towering, upturned New Romantic. Her last two albums, The Loneliest Time and its B-side sibling The Loveliest Time, saw Jepsen get a little older and weirder, embracing a bit of theater-kid melodrama here and some mushroomy indie pop there. They seemed to signify a new wisdom, acknowledging the occasional joys and multiplying frustrations that come from all that lusting and crying and fucking and pining through a wearier, more lived-through-it lens. A plainspoken theme weaves through her entire discography: Carly Rae Jepsen can’t help but feel it all, and there is always so much to feel.
In the interim between The Loveliest Time and Day and Night, her new double album, Jepsen married music producer and songwriting partner Cole M.G.N., and the two had a child, which begged the question: What will Carly Rae Jepsen’s music sound like when she’s found what she spent so many albums looking for? The unsurprising answer is that it’s complicated, that nothing is ever really settled. Day and Night finds Jepsen navigating an existential wilderness, as contented as she is curious, searching for the balance between who she is and how she was. It’s a very interior record, sung softly, as though to a mirror, and filled with the dueling visions of domestic bliss and painful recovered memories. You can’t write new chapters without revisiting the previous ones, she seems to say. It doesn’t work like that.
Day and Night is perhaps her strangest, most musically voracious work to date. She’s been increasingly chameleon-like recently, with songs like the French house banger “Psychedelic Switch” and gaseous groover “Kollage” tiptoeing into new territory, though she’s still so recognizably Carly. It’s no different across these twenty-four tracks. Even when her voice is treated more heavily than in the past, warped with Auto-Tune or sent through some particularly thick compression, it still has that blurred-edge softness, that slight verge-of-tears melancholy, those melodies that immediately bury themselves in the rivulets of your brain.
She tries on a number of new deliveries, like the stepped rise and fall of the vocal melody on “Blue Skies,” or the almost Toni Braxton-like huskiness she takes on during the pre-chorus of “Near and Far.” Though she knows her way around a hook—like on the plush “Habits of Creatures”—she goes the opposite direction, reducing the verses to a single root note that the other elements dance around. Jepsen somehow never gets lost in her experiments; even if they’re only base hits rather than home runs, the big swings usually connect.
The loose concept behind Day and Night is that the Day disc is a waking-hours, two-mimosa poolside kickback, while Night Ubers to the club with an extra pair of shoes in the bag. It’s a little on the nose in its thematic telegraphing, but sets the expectations well enough. Day is full of pastel tones, shuffling slacker drums, and a billowing atmosphere, an exploration of the wafting psych-pop that Jepsen began toying with on The Loneliest Time’s “Western Wind.”
Most of this side, like the opening twofer of “After All” and “Habits of Creatures,” is cast in the languid, post-coital glow of life with a new partner, content to waste hours lying in bed attempting to touch as much of their skin together as possible. But over its twelve songs, the morning sunlight fails, casting long, reaching shadows. A few sober moments, like on “Wild Child,” find Jepsen imploring her lover to have patience. “Settle me down, down, down, do the best you can / All kinds of trouble, but all of this trouble’s for you,” she sighs, promising, “It’s gonna hurt / Baby, I’m gonna hurt you.”
Night is full of middle-distance stares and sweaty, dissociative dance-floor reveries. It’s built to process heavy thoughts through movement, while still recognizing how they creep in during moments of catharsis. If we hold trauma in our bodies, it’s understandable that shaking it could bring up things we didn’t know we lodged deep in our core.
Both discs have a recognizable arc—happiness curdles slightly, leading to unexpected questions and inevitable comparisons to past loves, but there’s always a way back to you—but Night’s feels a little more defined, and perhaps a little more real in how it zigs and zags between euphoria and gloom. The desperation of “Don’t Leave Me On The Dancefloor” leads to the giddiness of “You Don’t Know How It Feels,” which leads to the fear and overwhelm of those feelings on “Near or Far.” The disc ends with Jepsen turning her face toward the beaming light on “Super Sage,” but there are no drums, perhaps an acknowledgment that maintaining the rhythm of a good relationship is a lifelong process.
What’s most striking about Day and Night is how spatially and texturally interesting it sounds as compared to most of Jepsen’s other work. The production on her albums typically hits a lot of pop signifiers: her voice is pedestaled in front of the instruments, long reverb tails emphasize the ends of bars, and tight harmonies are mixed low enough to create an almost imperceptible tension. Here, choral vocals darken the corners, time-stretched samples burst apart when beats drop, instruments wash into each other. Everything sounds cared for, as if placed into the stereo field with tweezers. There are tons of sly production tricks, like the live drums that sneak in during the second verse of “On Wires,” or the slight slapback delay that kisses Jespen’s voice on certain phrases, giving the track a hallucinatory sheen. For all its pop immediacy, Day and Night is an especially rewarding headphones listen, a complex machine creating something rapturously simple.
Despite the ambition and curiosity that color the album, it can be a slightly patchy listen. “Versailles,” an early cut on Day, feels completely out of place, its stuttering arrangement a little reminiscent of E•MO•TION Side B’s baffling “Store.” “Just a Little Walk on the Moon” meanders without ever committing to one of its lovely sections, and the verses on “Good Fine Alright” feel underwritten compared to the chorus’ power. Night’s missteps are mostly lyrical: On “Motivation,” an otherwise hip-shaking ballroom jam, Jepsen declares, deadpan, “We go hard in this family.” She invokes having “the courage of a lion” on “Diver,” a cliché that nearly derails an otherwise decent song.
But the sections where she and her collaborators hit a flow state, like the glorious run on Day from the War on Drugs-esque “Burning Heart” to the swelling psychedelia of “Soft,” or the back half of Night, which features the candlelit garage of “Hold Me to the Light” and the beachy house heater “No Labels, I Love You” (the first fruit of Jepsen and Cole M.G.N.’s team-up), are good reminders that when she’s on, Jepsen is one of the best pop songwriters in the game. Day and Night might not be the star-making statement she’s been chasing, but it is the sound of an artist eager to keep finding out who she is. [Interscope]
Dash Lewis is a writer and musician based in Richmond, VA with bylines at Pitchfork, SPIN, Bandcamp and more. When not noodling with synthesizers, he’s in search of a great sandwich. Find him online @gardenerjams.