Neutral Milk HotelBest Neutral Milk Hotel Albums Ranked
7.9
Avg Score
42
Opinions
5
Albums
28
Reviewers
Summary from 42 ratings
On Rate.fm, fans have rated Neutral Milk Hotel’s catalog across 5 albums from 42 opinions, with an overall average of 7.9/10. The top-rated Neutral Milk Hotel album is In the Aeroplane Over the Sea (1998) with a 7.9/10 average from 26 ratings, followed by On Avery Island and Ferris Wheel on Fire. The discography on Rate.fm spans 1996 to 2023. Two-Headed Boy, Pt. 2 ranks as the highest-rated Neutral Milk Hotel song on Rate.fm with a 9.5/10 average.
Two-Headed Boy, Pt. 2
Neutral Milk Hotel • 1998
Holland, 1945
Neutral Milk Hotel • 1998
April 8th (1992)
Neutral Milk Hotel • 2023
In the Aeroplane Over the Sea
“A lo-fi indie folk masterpiece of surreal, emotionally devastating beauty.”
In the Aeroplane Over the Sea
“The reissue of Neutral Milk Hotel’s cult classic offers another opportunity to measure its reach and influence. Jeff Mangum’s masterpiece mixes hushed folk, explosive brass, and unforgettable vocals that touch on pain, loss, memory, and hope.”
On Avery Island
“Each Sunday, Pitchfork takes an in-depth look at a significant album from the past, and any record not in our archives is eligible. Today, we revisit the oft-overshadowed debut from indie rock icons, a smaller and more intimate look into the mercurial world of Jeff Mangum.”
In the Aeroplane Over the Sea
“À primeira ouvida desavisada é um disco estranho, distorcido demais mas depois de respirar e entender que é ~diferente~ consegui pegar a vibe. Me lembrou tipo a trilha sonora de filme independente que fala de um protagonista solitário, estranho e depressivo. Gostei, cheguei no final bem diferente de como comecei. Uma coisa que gostei muito foram dos metais que em algum momento até achei que lembra los hermanos. Adorei a voz do vocalista. Vibe bar do braga total Faixa favorita the fool Apesar de achar a voz do mano mt mt legal, essa foi minha favorita e não tem voz. Menção tbm pra untitled que é a música com menos play do disco de forma errada. Nota 8 de 10 Queria dar 7, mas dei 8 pq eu ouviria de novo pela interessância e não pq amei muito.”
In the Aeroplane Over the Sea
“If I could give negative numbers I would this album is an atrocity to the art of music this made me physically cringe anyone who thinks this is a “10/10” is a sheep and is following the crowd open ur eyes this is a dumpster fire in a minefield this is terrible Two Headed Boy is one of the creepiest songs ever and Oh Comely shouldn’t be out for the public this album needs to be taken down i genuinely lost intelligence and brain cells bc of this piece of crap”
In the Aeroplane Over the Sea
“The songs were creepy and there was only one good part which was just a transition from “Two-Headed Boy” to “The Fool” and “The fool” and “untitled” don’t have lyrics and the instrumentals are weird.”