Mariah CareyBest Mariah Carey Albums Ranked
7.5
Avg Score
59
Opinions
43
Albums
12
Reviewers
Summary from 59 ratings
On Rate.fm, fans have rated Mariah Carey’s catalog across 43 albums from 59 opinions, with an overall average of 7.5/10. The top-rated Mariah Carey album is Daydream (1995) with a 8.4/10 average from 4 ratings, followed by Caution and Butterfly. The discography on Rate.fm spans 1990 to 2025. Fantasy ranks as the highest-rated Mariah Carey song on Rate.fm with a 9.7/10 average.
The Emancipation Of Mimi
“Each Sunday, Pitchfork takes an in-depth look at a significant album from the past, and any record not in our archives is eligible. Today we revisit Mariah Carey’s triumphant comeback, an album that captured the zeitgeist of 2000s R&B and resurrected a pop icon.”
The Rarities
“The Rarities is the newest testament to Mariah Carey’s legendary artistry”
Here For It All
“Mariah Carey has had the privilege to not care about making new music for a while now. The pop icon has built such a towering legacy over the course of her phenomenal career: 19 Billboard Hot 100 Number ones, six Grammys, and a catalogue that’s influenced an entire generation of artists from Adele to Ariana Grande. The elusive chanteuse could hang up her mic now, but she’s back again with her 16th”
The Emancipation Of Mimi
“From one of the biggest hit makers of her generation beloved by most including myself comes her final chance to be free and make the music she wants. And .... There is not a hit on the album. In fact, it is all drab forgettable r and b dance music ish stuff. I am going to get rid of this asap. Glad Mimi feels free finally. Good for her for sure. Bad for the rest of us who liked her old music waaaaaaay better!”
Mariah Carey
“im sorry but all 90s ballads sound exactly the same so i only enjoyed the upbeat songs and they were pretty good”