IdlewildBest Idlewild Albums Ranked
7.5
Avg Score
10
Opinions
12
Albums
5
Reviewers
Summary from 10 ratings
On Rate.fm, fans have rated Idlewild’s catalog across 12 albums from 10 opinions, with an overall average of 7.5/10. The top-rated Idlewild album is Idlewild (2025) with a 9.0/10 average from 1 rating, followed by 100 Broken Windows and Warnings / Promises. The discography on Rate.fm spans 1998 to 2025.
Idlewild
“The march of time can’t diminish Idlewild's flame”
100 Broken Windows
“You know Jake. Every high school class had at least one, usually several. He was the kid who was always on time to class, always got straight A's, read Shakespeare for fun, and calculated the gravitational fields of black holes in his spare time. But no one really picked on him because he pretty much kept to himself. Occasionally, people snickered when he had to give a presentation in front of the”
Interview Music
“Yes, Idlewild are very much still a thing. Though they crashed into indie consciousness with the howling but literate snarl of 1998’s ‘Captain’ and ‘Hope Is Important’, the more nuanced, cult classic ‘100 Broken Windows’ would see the Scottish punks suddenly taken quite seriously. A couple of more mature and stately albums followed, but by the time Idlewild dropped the limp ‘Make Another World’ i”