HorsegirlBest Horsegirl Albums Ranked
8.0
Avg Score
22
Opinions
4
Albums
12
Reviewers
Summary from 22 ratings
On Rate.fm, fans have rated Horsegirl’s catalog across 4 albums from 22 opinions, with an overall average of 8.0/10. The top-rated Horsegirl album is Phonetics On and On (2025) with a 8.2/10 average from 11 ratings, followed by Versions of Modern Performance. The discography on Rate.fm spans 2022 to 2025. Ballroom Dance Scene ranks as the highest-rated Horsegirl song on Rate.fm with a 7.1/10 average.
Phonetics On and On
“On Horsegirl’s 2022 debut, Versions of Modern Performance, three Chicagoan gen Z musicians robed themselves in the noise of gen X indie-rock, their chaotic carapace of distortion and dynamics housing soft-centred pop and bruised melodies. But its fuzzy charms are eclipsed by this quantum leap of a second album, a masterpiece of intention and purposefulness. Produced by Cate Le Bon, Phonetics On an”
Phonetics On and On
“Horsegirl have deftly bridged the wide gulfs between archetypal and ingenious by making music that, while indebted to the sound of decades' past, never feels like pastiche. This isn't the sound of three dabblers with expansive (and expensive) record collections; it's musicians playing the style of music they love with sincerity and intention, dog-eared copies of If You're Feeling Sinister be damne”
Phonetics On and On
“On their Cate Le Bon-produced sophomore record, Phonetics On and On, the quirky Chicago-to-New York trio grow up and grow into their influences.”