YsJoanna Newsom · 2006

pitchfork

9.4

“The inimitable singer-songwriter quickly follows the formally ambitious Ys with a three-song EP consisting of one new song and two old ones, recorded live in the studio with four members of her acoustic touring band.”

ben

8.8

“Some lulls in the middle definitely. But the opener is all time. I think this is her best project.”