“With Charlie, Charlie Puth comes full circle, blending the polished pop hooks we know him for with a more personal, introspective side. As a fan, it’s exciting to hear him leaning into his own sound instead of chasing trends. The production is tight, the melodies are catchy, and his voice carries more warmth and nuance than ever. There are standout tracks that feel instantly classic in his catalog, but a few moments drag a bit, making the album feel slightly uneven. Still, the honesty and charm shine through, and it’s clear he’s growing as both a songwriter and performer. For anyone who’s followed him from the start, Charlie is a satisfying listen that reinforces why he deserves his spot in modern pop.”
“It’s such a shame that the production on this album is mostly bad, since I really do like a lot of its songs. The vocals are processed to oblivion and the beats are super derivative. There are a few highlights that I go back to, but its flaws are too blaring to ignore. Favs: Smells Like Me, Tears On My Piano, I Don’t Think That I Like Her, No More Drama Not good: Loser, When You’re Sad I’m Sad”
